Baseball Card Storage and Collecting

Collectables, Storing Vintage


If the opening of baseball season this month inspires you to start up or grow your baseball card collection, Public Storage is here to help, with tips on how collecting works and how you can safely store and organize your tiny treasures. We talked to the owner of a sports memorabilia shop who’s been selling cards since he was 12. Mike Sablow held on to his first pack for just a few hours, until he realized he could turn a profit on players someone else wanted.

Baseball cards for some of the most popular players: Sandy Koufax Mickey Mantle and Hank Aaron

In fact, when people come through the doors of Mike’s Southern California shop, aptly named Cardboard Legends, it is usually because they want to make the same gamble, that what they buy today will have more value to someone else at sometime in the future. Experienced card collectors also usually have a system for how they store their goods. And they aren’t as careless as we were decades ago, when old collections were routinely trashed. Now the thinking is, “let’s buy this and put it away. Let’s protect it,” Mike said.

Coincidentally, Mike does use Public Storage for extra inventory of duplicate cards he’s also got in the shop. He stores them raised off the ground in plastic storage bins. Items in the shop are kept in various individual clear card sleeves. Mike double protects them in very thin “penny sleeves” within thicker sleeves. The best are acid-free so that they don’t degrade your collection.

baseball card storage sleeves

He then stores them either on shelves or in baseball card boxes.

Baseball card storage box with cards

You can also buy other card protectors such as page sleeves that store multiple cards in a notebook. Regardless of their storage choice, customers also like to organize the cards, often by year and alphabetically by player.

baseball card storage in plastic sleeves in a notebook with dodger cards

Hard-core collectors wear white cotton gloves when handling the cards outside their polyester protectors. After all, the most valuable card sold for $2.8 million in 2007. That card featuring Pittsburgh short stop Honus Wagner was sold in packs of tobacco in the early 1900’s but is rare because it was discontinued shortly after production began.

Mike has seen baseball card collecting change dramatically from when he was a kid. There are still parents jumping in as an activity with their kids, but starting in the late 1980’s and early 1990’s, money became a greater focus, especially with the production of an increasing array of premium versions featuring pieces of signed uniform fabric or holograms. “Therer’s more hype,” Mike said.

signed uniform piece from dodger player

Thick plastic cases to protect baseball and other sports cards

The increased popularity is also driving up competition for the all-important rookie cards. Unfortunately, if a new player is destined for greatness, everyone already knows about him and is paying top dollar. The internet is also now a major marketplace for Mike and other sellers and buyers, who bid top dollar for what they want. It’s a tough game out there!

Mike’s top pick for card pricing websites is But he said a search on eBay for current auction prices is probably even more accurate.

Do you have any more tips or ideas? Please share! Facebook, Pinterest, Google , or Twitter!

by Ann Griffith Google

Photo upload terms and conditions

  1. Maximum file size accepted is 5 MB.
  2. Public Storage reserves the right in its sole discretion to decline to use any photo submitted.
  3. Images must be your own.
  4. You must have permission of anyone featured in the photo before uploading for use by Public Storage.
  5. Photos must not infringe upon the copyrights or trademarks of any person or entity.
  6. By submitting, you agree that Public Storage can use and shall own the photos and all rights therein.
  7. You understand and acknowledge that you are receiving no compensation in exchange for submitting images, though some images may also be used as part of a giveaway if announced on social media for that time period.
  8. Submitting the photo does not automatically enter you to participate in any contest or sweepstakes.
  9. By submitting a photo, you agree that Public Storage may use your image (and the likeness of anyone featured in that image) for advertising or the like and in any media of any kind, including any social media channel, without compensation of any kind. The photo may be used in this matter at any time and without further notification or release. The photo will be kept by Public Storage and not returned to you.
  10. By submitting a photo, you agree that Public Storage may contact you with questions about you and other people and activities represented in the image.
  11. By submitting a photo, you agree to defend, hold harmless and indemnify Public Storage and each and all of the agents, representatives, insurers, employees, attorneys, successors, subsidiaries, parent companies, affiliated companies, assigns, officers, directors, and shareholders of Public Storage, both present and past (collectively referred to herein as “Public Storage”) and the like against any and all claims, including claims of infringement of any intellectual property rights, proprietary rights, rights or privacy and publicity, moral rights and rights of attribution raise by third parties in connection with any photo submitted.
  12. Public Storage is not responsible for any injury, losses or damages of any kind resulting from the submission of your photo.
  13. Public Storage assumes no responsibility for letting you know whether the photo was or was not used.
  14. Public Storage assumes no responsibility for notifying you of why your photo is or is not used.
  15. Public Storage assumes no responsibility for any error, omission, deletion, defect, theft, destruction or alteration of any photo.
  16. You release Public Storage and each and all of the agents, representatives, insurers, employees, attorneys, successors, subsidiaries, parent companies, affiliated companies, assigns, officers, directors, and shareholders of Public Storage, both present and past from and against any and all claims which you have now or may have in the future for invasion of privacy, defamation, violations of rights of publicity or any other cause of action arising out of distribution, copying, display or other use of the photo in any way.
  17. Your submission shall be exclusively governed by the laws of the State of California, without regard to conflicts of law provisions. You (or your parent/legal guardian if you are a minor) submit to the jurisdiction of California and agree that any dispute shall be resolved by binding arbitration to be held in Los Angeles, CA via the Rules for Commercial Arbitration of the American Arbitration Association. In the event that arbitration is prohibited by law, you agree that any lawsuit or legal action with respect to any submitted materials must be brought in the state and federal courts in Los Angeles County, Los Angeles. You and Public Storage agree that claims may only be brought in an individual capacity and in the name of an individual person or entity and that claims must proceed on an individual and non-class and non-representative basis.